One Batter – Two Classic Cakes


Whole cake for One Batter Two Classic CakesTwo Classic Cakes from German Chocolate Cake batter, makes either one the star.   I have to admit I am one of the few people in America that doesn’t get one of the Two Classic Cakes – The Red Velvet Cake.  Traditionally a white cake with the barest amount of cocoa colored with red dye to which a bit of vinegar is added to make it even more red which, after baking, is filled and finished with Cream Cheese Frosting.

To make the cake part more interesting at the bakery, we used the Second Classic Cake – the German Chocolate Cake to which we added red dye and a little vinegar.  As you can see from the photos – red it is.  The cake has one of the most tender crumbs of any cake.Cut pieces for One Batter Two Classic Cakes

Because these are very tall, very elegant cakes I have increased the finishes/fillings for each of the cakes.  A single recipe of the incredible pecan coconut filling and frosting for the German Chocolate Cake had to be increased by one half.

If making the German Chocolate Cake, make the filling/frosting the day before to allow it to set up in the refrigerator.  It will make all the difference when assembling the cake.

When making the cream cheese filling and frosting do not get the butter too soft or the frosting will be droopy.  Refrigerate if need to stiffen it up.

For the photo, I made the German Chocolate Cake batter below once.  I then divided the batter in half and added half the amount of red food coloring and vinegar for the Red Velvet Cake.  A recipe for a nine inch cake will yield two 6 inch cakes.  The recipe below is for one 9″ cake.  Additions to turn the German Chocolate Cake into a 9″ Red Velvet Cake are listed below.

As to the photography for this blog, Mike had an accident and I had to take my own pictures.  Knowing absolutely nothing about his cameras, I used my iPhone except for the photos of the  finished cakes.  I almost drove myself nuts trying to make the cake and photograph it too. I would remember after I did something that I should have taken a picture.     I salute all of you who can manage both.  I know the copyright reads T. Mike Fletcher but honestly, at this  point, I really don’t care.

German Chocolate Cake
4 ounces semisweet chocolate
1/2 cup boiling water*
1 cup butter, room temperature (2 sticks, 225 grams or 8 ounces)
2 cups sugar, divided (400 grams or 14 ounces)
4 eggs, separated
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 1/2 cups cake flour + 2 tablespoons* (310 grams or scant 11 scant  ounces)
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 cup buttermilk

For Red Velvet Cake – All the ingredients are the same as the German Chocolate Cake with the following substitution and additions.
*Reduce the water to 1/3 cup water
Add 2 tablespoons red food coloring
Add 1 teaspoon vinegarRed coloring and vinegar for One Batter Two Classic CakesMelt chocolate in 1/3 cup water.  Add the red food coloring and vinegar. Set aside. Use where specified in directions below.

Line three 9 inch cake pans with parchment. Spray only the center of the rounds. Do not spray the sides. Set aside. Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.

Chop chocolate coarsely and melt in boiling water. (If making the Red Velvet Cake use the ingredients for the Red Velvet Cake above and continue as below.)  Cool.

Cream the butter and 1 1/2 cups sugar until fluffy and pale in color. Add yolks, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Add the vanilla and chocolate; scraping down and beating until all is blended and smooth.

Whisk the flour, baking soda, baking powder and salt together; add alternately with buttermilk (starting and ending with flour).Chocolate batter for One Batter Two Classic CakesIn a clean bowl, beat egg whites until soft peaks form; add remaining sugar slowly in a steady stream. Beat until fairly stiff. Egg whites beaten for One Batter Two Classic CakesStir 1/3 of the egg whites into the batter to lighten it.Egg whites to lighten the chocolate batter for One Batter Two Classic CakesEgg whites mixed into batter for One Batter Two Classic Cakes Fold the remainder of the whites into the batter. Remainder of egg whites in batter for One Batter Two CakesEgg whites folded into batter for One Batter Two Classic CakesDivide equally between the three pans (about 490 grams per pan); smoothing and leveling.Chocolate and Red batters for One Batter Two Classic CakesBake for 25 to 30 minutes until tester comes out clean and center springs back when lightly touched.

Coconut-Pecan Frosting for the German Chocolate Cake
1 1/2 cups evaporated milk
1 1/2 cups sugar (300 grams or 10 1/2 ounces)
5 slightly beaten egg yolks
3/4 cup butter, cut into pieces (170 grams or 6 ounces)
2 teaspoons vanilla
2 1/2 cups Baker’s Angel Flake Coconut (210 grams or 9 ounces)
2 1/4 cups chopped pecans (170 or 6 ounces)

Combine evaporated milk, sugar, yolks and butter in a saucepan. Cook and stir over medium heat until thickened,  about 192 degrees.  Do not boil.   Add vanilla, coconut and pecans. Chill until set.

Yields: Approximately 1100 grams

After the filling is completely cooled, place 1/3 (365 grams or 12 3/4 ounces) of frosting between the layers and on top.

Cream Cheese Frosting For Red Velvet Cake
1 1/2 sticks butter (170 grams, 6 ounces or 3/4 cup)
12 ounces cream cheese (340 grams)
1 1/2 pounds powdered sugar (680 grams or 24 ounces)
1 teaspoon vanilla

Combine all in a mixing bowl and beat until smooth and fluffy.  Spread between the layers and undercoat cake, reserving enough to apply a finish coat and decorative edging.

While there are many American Classic cakes, these two are among the most requested.

Pastry has not only been my profession, but my passion. If there is anything in particular you would like to see or any questions about baking or pastry, please let me know. Be sure to subscribe so you don't miss a post!
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

14 thoughts on “One Batter – Two Classic Cakes

  1. Mani

    Hi Helen

    Commendable job with photography! After knowing that you took the pics I scrolled back to to see them.

    I hope Mike is ok now.

    I loved the crumb of these cakes. I hate soggy, doughy or dry cakes. I crave for such crumb. It’s Perfect! If I can get a recipe which I can convert into different cakes then nothing like it.

    Take care and thanx for this great recipe.

  2. Ingrid

    Hello Helen,
    Thank you so much for this recipe.

    As I was looking through it, I saw that the sugar amounts in the cake ( 2cups = 200g) wouldn’t be comparable with the sugar amount in the oconut-pecan frosting (1 1/2 cups = 300g). While you are there, could you please check the icing sugar amount in the cheesecake frosting as well? Thank you.

    I love it that you give the weights in grams!

    By the way, do you differentiate between powdered sugar and icing sugar? Some pastry chefs in America state that powdered sugar has cornstarch added. I live now in Australia and we have pure icing sugar and icing sugar mix (with cornstarch) available.

    Your reply and your fabulous recipes are very much appreciated!

    1. hfletcher Post author

      Hi Ingrid: Thanks so much for catching this. I corrected the recipe. I cup of granulated sugar equals 200 gram or 7 ounces. So the 2 cups of sugar should be 400 grams or 14 ounces.

      In the states we do not have icing sugar. The powdered sugar in the states contains 3% cornstarch. So the powdered sugar I use would be your icing sugar mix as long as it contains 3% cornstarch. However, I don’t think the cornstarch matters as long as the sugar is a powdered consistency.

      Thank you for your very kind words.


  3. Vali

    I do love your blog! It’s so knowledgeable and wise. Fluffy, squealing, and virtually clueless but beautifully-photographed baking blogs abound nowadays, but yours is old-school, somehow: correct and experienced. And occasionally very funny.*

    I’m curious about adding vinegar: is it for flavour, or to assist in the rising, or…?

    * I hope Mike is OK!

    1. hfletcher Post author

      Hi Vali: The vinegar has a chemical reaction with the cocoa that turns it red. So, it enhances the red of the dye. Hope this helps. Mike is just great. He took a fall, face down onto concrete January 1st. After 7 hours in the ER he came home and I hardly recognized him. Just glad my son and grandson were with him. We are extremely grateful there were no broken bones and he how looks like the man I have been married to for 53 years. Thank you so much for asking.

      1. Vali

        Oh my goodness, that must have been most alarming! Poor Mike, and poor everyone else involved. Glad he’s better now (that’s quick!).

        Thanks for explaining the vinegar!

  4. Ingrid

    I too agree about the red velvet cake…I just don’t get it. Now the German Chocolate cake is something to get excited about. Thanks for sharing your recipes, love the blog, and your photos are fine.

  5. Nikki

    Count me in on another that has not stepped on the Red Velvet Cake bandwagon. If I want a CHOCOLATE cake give me a chocolate cake, if I don’t want chocolate cake…call a doctor. I always loved German’s Chocolate Cake until I saw a twist to it done on a show. A guest baker, Julia Baker, did a German Chocolate Souffle Cake. I have made it several times and it is always a hit.
    I will have to give this one a try. I have not done one by whipping the egg whites then folding them in. I anticipate a higher rising cake. Thanks for another recipe to add to my “to do” list.

  6. Rockyrd

    I have to say I am with you on the red velvet thing. If you close your eyes when you eat it, you’d never know what it is, well…ones I have eaten anyway, maybe not yours if I had it.
    And for me the german chocolate cake is the icing/filling. Just give me a bowl of the stuff.
    The photos look great so don’t worry so much.
    Hope Mike is better real soon.

    1. hfletcher Post author

      Hi Rockyrd: You are too funny. Did you notice I increased the amount of filling. I agree -really good. Just finished a piece. The perk of this blog is eating the results. Mike is fine. Please see my reply to Vali and thank you for asking about him.

Comments are closed.